US Soccer Podcast Power Ranking: Top 5 Podcasts for Every Fan

This article provides a definitive power ranking of the top five US soccer podcasts, offering essential listening for fans eager to deepen their engagement with the sport’s evolving landscape, from tactical breakdowns to insightful interviews and comprehensive league coverage.

For the dedicated enthusiast of American soccer, the realm of podcasts has become an indispensable resource, offering unparalleled access to analysis, interviews, and community insights. As the sport continues its rapid ascent in popularity across the United States, finding the truly standout audio experiences amidst a burgeoning field can be a challenge. This comprehensive US Soccer Podcast Power Ranking: The Top 5 Shows Every Fan Should Be Listening To serves as your definitive guide, curated to enhance your understanding and enjoyment of the beautiful game, from the intricate tactics of MLS to the broader narratives of the US National Teams.

the evolving soundscape of US soccer commentary

The growth of soccer in the United States isn’t just visible on the field; it’s profoundly audible through the blossoming landscape of dedicated podcasts. These platforms have transformed how fans connect with the sport, moving beyond traditional broadcasts to offer deeper dives, unfiltered opinions, and unique perspectives. This evolution mirrors the sport’s increasing sophistication, demanding equally sophisticated and nuanced commentary.

Historically, soccer coverage in the US was limited, often relegated to niche segments or international broadcasts. The advent of digital media and the podcasting boom, however, democratized access to information and analysis. Suddenly, passionate fans and seasoned journalists alike could launch their own shows, sharing their expertise and building communities around shared interests. This shift has not only enriched the discourse surrounding US soccer but has also played a significant role in its mainstream acceptance and cultural integration.

from niche to mainstream: podcasting’s role in soccer’s ascension

Podcasts have been instrumental in bridging the gap between casual interest and fervent fandom. They provide a space where complex tactical discussions can unfold, where the human stories behind the headlines are explored, and where the nuances of player development and league dynamics are given their due. This level of detail and accessibility is often difficult to achieve in traditional media formats, which typically cater to broader audiences or tighter time constraints.

• Accessibility: Podcasts are available on demand, fitting into listeners’ busy schedules.
• Depth of Coverage: They allow for longer, more detailed discussions on specific topics.
• Community Building: Many podcasts foster strong listener communities through Q&A segments and social media engagement.
• Diverse Perspectives: The independent nature of podcasting encourages a wider range of voices and viewpoints.

The transition from a niche interest to a mainstream phenomenon for US soccer owes much to these audio platforms. They’ve provided a consistent, high-quality stream of content that educates, entertains, and connects fans in ways that were previously unimaginable. This section sets the stage for understanding why these five podcasts are not just good, but essential, recognizing their contribution to the sport’s narrative and community.

Moreover, the interactive nature of many of these shows means that fans are not just passive consumers of content. They can submit questions, participate in polls, and engage directly with hosts and guests, fostering a sense of ownership and belonging within the larger soccer community. This dynamic interaction elevates the podcast experience from mere listening to active participation, further solidifying the bond between the sport, its commentators, and its passionate audience.

methodology behind our power ranking

Curating a definitive list of the top US soccer podcasts is no small feat, given the sheer volume and varied nature of content available. Our methodology is rooted in a comprehensive approach that prioritizes both quantitative metrics and qualitative assessments, ensuring a ranking that reflects true value for the listener. This isn’t just about popularity; it’s about impact, expertise, and consistent quality.

Firstly, we established key criteria for evaluation, acknowledging that different listeners seek different things from a podcast. These criteria encompassed everything from production quality and host expertise to the breadth of topics covered and overall audience engagement. Each podcast was meticulously reviewed against these benchmarks, with a focus on delivering a balanced and objective assessment.

key evaluation criteria for podcast excellence

To ensure a robust and fair ranking, we focused on several core pillars of podcasting excellence. These pillars served as the touchstones against which each potential candidate for our top five was measured.

• Expertise and Authority: Do the hosts possess deep knowledge of US soccer? Is their commentary insightful and evidence-based? We looked for individuals with reputable backgrounds in journalism, coaching, or professional playing.
• Production Quality: Is the audio clear and consistent? Is the editing professional? Good technical execution significantly enhances the listening experience.
• Content Relevance and Diversity: Does the podcast cover a wide range of relevant topics, from MLS and NWSL to USMNT/USWNT and youth development? Is the content fresh and engaging, avoiding repetitive narratives?
• Audience Engagement: How well does the podcast interact with its listeners? Do they address fan questions, encourage discussion, and build a sense of community?
• Consistency and Timeliness: Is the podcast released regularly with fresh content? Does it respond quickly to breaking news and significant events within US soccer?

Beyond these primary criteria, we also considered feedback from the broader soccer community, delving into listener reviews, forum discussions, and social media sentiment. While not the sole determinant, this qualitative feedback provided valuable insights into the listener experience and perception of each show. The combination of objective metrics and subjective insights allowed us to construct a ranking that is both analytical and reflective of current fan preferences.

Our goal was not just to list popular podcasts, but to spotlight those that genuinely elevate the listener’s understanding and enjoyment of US soccer. This rigorous methodology ensured that each podcast in our top five truly earned its place, representing the pinnacle of audio content for American soccer fans.

the contenders: a brief overview of the elite

Before diving into the definitive power ranking, it’s essential to acknowledge the landscape of high-quality US soccer podcasts. While many shows offer valuable insights, a select few consistently rise above the rest, becoming indispensable listening for fans throughout the season and beyond. These contenders distinguish themselves through their depth, consistency, and unique approach to covering the sport.

The criteria explored in the previous section were applied rigorously to a broad pool of podcasts, narrowing them down to the absolute elite. This overview briefly introduces the caliber of shows that are setting the standard in US soccer audio commentary.

a competitive field of exceptional shows

The proliferation of soccer content means that simply producing a podcast isn’t enough; it must stand out in a crowded, competitive field. The shows profiled here generally excel in several facets, from their journalistic integrity to their ability to foster vibrant community discussions.

• The Journalists’ Perspective: Podcasts led by veteran journalists often provide unparalleled access and analytical depth.
• The Fan’s Voice: Shows that effectively channel and address the burning questions of the fan base resonate deeply.
• Tactical Deep Dives: Some podcasts specialize in breaking down the game’s strategic elements, appealing to more analytical listeners.

Each of the podcasts considered for our top five brings a distinct flavor to the table, whether it’s through interview-driven content, rapid-fire news analysis, or in-depth tactical breakdowns. What unites them is a shared commitment to high-quality content and a genuine passion for the growth of soccer in America. This preliminary look at the elite sets the stage for our definitive ranking, highlighting the rich variety and excellence available to US soccer enthusiasts.

The process of selecting these top contenders involved sifting through countless hours of content, evaluating host chemistry, guest caliber, and segment structure. It became clear that the best podcasts aren’t just informative; they are also engaging, often entertaining, and always thought-provoking. They challenge listeners to think critically about the game and encourage a deeper appreciation for its complexities. The upcoming ranking will detail precisely why these particular shows have earned their place at the summit.

#5: the american soccer analysis podcast

Securing the fifth spot in our ultimate power ranking is the American Soccer Analysis Podcast, a show that caters specifically to the analytical mind of the US soccer fan. What sets this podcast apart is its unwavering commitment to data-driven insights and advanced metrics, providing a level of tactical and performance analysis rarely found elsewhere. It’s a goldmine for those who want to understand the ‘why’ behind the results, rather than just the ‘what’.

This podcast, backed by the reputable American Soccer Analysis website, leverages an extensive database of statistical information to dissect individual player performances, team strategies, and broader league trends. The hosts, typically a rotating cast of bright analytical minds, bring a strong academic rigor to their discussions, translating complex data into understandable and actionable insights for the average listener, while also challenging more experienced analysts.

unveiling the narratives behind the numbers

While statistics can sometimes feel abstract, the American Soccer Analysis Podcast excels at using them to tell compelling stories about the game. They don’t just present numbers; they interpret them, explaining their significance and how they contribute to a team’s success or failure, or a player’s true impact.

• Data-backed discussions: Every argument is supported by relevant statistics and analytical models.
• Tactical breakdowns: Deep dives into formations, player roles, and strategic adjustments.
• Player evaluation: Objective assessments of player performance beyond traditional goals and assists.
• Future trend analysis: Forecasting potential developments in MLS and the national teams based on statistical patterns.

The consistency with which they produce high-quality, research-intensive content is commendable. Their ability to contextualize advanced metrics within real-game scenarios makes every episode a learning experience. For fans who appreciate the strategic nuances and quantitative aspects of soccer, this podcast is an invaluable resource, providing a distinct perspective that complements more traditional commentary. It’s not just about who won or lost, but how and why, explained through the lens of sophisticated data.

The dedication to transparent methodology and the willingness to debate different analytical approaches also adds significant value, making the show feel like an open academic forum for soccer. It’s perfect for those who enjoy challenging assumptions and exploring the finer points of strategic play, truly earning its place among the top tier of US soccer podcasts.

#4: the total soccer show

Climbing into the fourth spot is The Total Soccer Show, a podcast that stands out for its balanced approach, combining insightful analysis with a consistently engaging and often humorous presentation. Hosted by Taylor Rockwell and Daryl Grove (and now a broader team building on Daryl’s legacy), the show has cultivated a loyal following by delivering comprehensive coverage of MLS, USMNT, and USWNT news, always with a critical yet accessible perspective.

What makes The Total Soccer Show a consistent favorite is the chemistry between its hosts, who manage to break down complex soccer topics into digestible segments. They cover a wide array of topics, from match reviews and previews to thoughtful debates on tactical decisions and broader league narratives. Their ability to connect with listeners on a personal level, often incorporating fan questions and feedback, fosters a strong sense of community.

balancing depth with approachability

The Total Soccer Show masterfully navigates the line between delivering deep analytical content and remaining broadly appealing. They delve into serious soccer discussions without ever becoming overly academic or inaccessible, inviting listeners of all knowledge levels into the conversation.

• Comprehensive coverage: Addresses major topics across MLS, NWSL, and international US soccer.
• Engaging host dynamic: The chemistry between hosts makes for an enjoyable listening experience.
• Timely news analysis: Reacts quickly and thoughtfully to breaking news and game results.
• Fan interaction: Regularly features listener questions and comments, making the audience feel part of the show.

Their strength lies in their versatility. One episode might feature a detailed tactical breakdown of an MLS match, while the next could be a passionate debate about the future of the US National Teams. This breadth, coupled with a consistent commitment to quality production and authentic delivery, ensures that listeners are always informed, entertained, and feel connected to the broader US soccer conversation. The show’s longevity and continued relevance speak volumes about its enduring appeal and its pivotal role in the US soccer podcast landscape.

The Total Soccer Show truly embodies the spirit of informed fan engagement, making it a must-listen for anyone looking to stay abreast of the latest US soccer developments while enjoying a vibrant and opinionated discussion. This blend of expertise and entertainment justly places it high on our power ranking.

#3: soccer morning (the ryan bailey show)

Holding firmly at the third position in our power ranking is Soccer Morning (The Ryan Bailey Show). This podcast, driven by the unique voice and perspective of its host, Ryan Bailey, offers a distinct blend of insightful commentary, sharp wit, and a no-holds-barred approach to discussing US soccer. It’s a show that doesn’t shy away from controversy or critique, providing a refreshing and often humorous counterpoint to more conventional sports analysis.

Ryan Bailey’s style is characterized by his passion, his deep historical knowledge of the sport, and his masterful ability to weave current events with broader narratives. While the show primarily focuses on MLS, USMNT, and USWNT, Bailey often connects these topics to the wider world of international soccer, offering a global context that enriches the discussion. His interviews are known for their directness and their capacity to elicit genuine, often surprising, responses from guests.

a fearless and insightful voice in US soccer

What truly distinguishes Soccer Morning is its audacious and often opinionated approach. Ryan Bailey brings a level of personality and candidness that makes the show incredibly engaging, attracting listeners who appreciate a host unwilling to pull punches when discussing the state of the game.

• Candid commentary: Offers unfiltered opinions and critiques on major US soccer topics.
• Engaging interviews: Features insightful conversations with a diverse range of guests.
• Historical context: Connects current events to the rich history and evolution of soccer.
• Humor and personality: Bailey’s distinct wit and passion make for a highly entertaining listen.

The podcast excels at providing an authentic fan experience, translating the debates and discussions that happen among friends at a pub into a professionally produced audio format. His ability to blend serious analysis with comedic timing keeps listeners hooked, proving that deep insights don’t always need to be delivered with a solemn tone. For those seeking an alternative, often provocative, but always informed perspective on American soccer, Soccer Morning is an essential listen that earns its high spot on this ranking.

Bailey’s commitment to addressing the elephants in the room, challenging prevailing narratives, and injecting genuine emotion into his commentary ensures that each episode is not just informative but also memorable. It’s a show that actively contributes to the vibrancy and critical thinking within the US soccer fan base.

#2: the athletic soccer show

Taking the impressive second place in our power ranking is The Athletic Soccer Show, a podcast that leverages the unparalleled journalistic resources of The Athletic to deliver premium, in-depth analysis of US soccer. This show distinguishes itself through its access to a formidable roster of respected journalists and insiders, who provide a level of reporting, insight, and breaking news coverage that is difficult for other podcasts to match independently.

The Athletic’s commitment to quality journalism translates seamlessly into its audio content. The podcast typically features a rotating cast of The Athletic’s top soccer writers – including the likes of Jeff Rueter, Paul Tenorio, and Meg Linehan – each bringing their specialized knowledge to cover various facets of MLS, NWSL, and the US National Teams. The discussions are always well-researched, balanced, and reflect a deep understanding of the intricacies of the game, both on and off the pitch.

unrivalled journalistic depth and expert analysis

The primary draw of The Athletic Soccer Show is its ability to provide reporting from the very heart of US soccer. By drawing on the expertise of journalists who are regularly breaking stories and conducting interviews at the highest levels of the sport, the podcast offers an unparalleled level of authoritative content.

• Exclusive insights: Access to reporting from leading journalists covering US soccer.
• Diverse perspectives: Features multiple experts, offering varied angles on key topics.
• In-depth discussions: Goes beyond headlines to explore the nuances and implications of major events.
• Professional production: High-quality audio and a polished presentation consistent with The Athletic’s brand.

From transfer rumors to tactical breakdowns, and from league governance to player development, The Athletic Soccer Show covers it all with a meticulous attention to detail. The hosts and guests provide well-reasoned arguments, often offering unique perspectives gleaned from their direct contacts within the sport. For the fan who demands the highest level of journalistic integrity and expert analysis, this podcast is an absolute must-listen, consistently delivering content that shapes the conversation around American soccer and prepares listeners for what’s next.

Its strength lies not just in its journalistic pedigree but also in its ability to synthesize complex information into accessible and engaging discussions, making it a cornerstone for serious US soccer followers.

#1: soccer cooligans

Crowning our US Soccer Podcast Power Ranking: The Top 5 Shows Every Fan Should Be Listening To is none other than Soccer Cooligans. Jesse Marsch and Alexis Guerreros have created a unique and beloved space at the intersection of soccer fandom and comedic genius. This podcast isn’t just about analyzing the game; it’s about celebrating the joy, frustration, absurdity, and profound emotional rollercoaster that comes with being a true soccer fan. It’s a show that makes you laugh, think, and feel more connected to the global soccer community.

What elevates Soccer Cooligans to the top spot is its unparalleled ability to blend serious soccer analysis with infectious humor and genuine passion. While they cover MLS, USMNT, USWNT, and major international leagues, their approach is distinctly human and inherently entertaining. They engage in lively debates, conduct hilarious interviews, and frequently interact with their loyal fanbase, fostering a vibrant and inclusive community.

the ultimate blend of humor, passion, and soccer insight

Soccer Cooligans has redefined what a soccer podcast can be, proving that deep knowledge and critical analysis can coexist with genuine laughter and playful banter. Their dynamic, often irreverent, yet always respectful approach to the sport has resonated deeply with a broad audience.

• Unmatched entertainment value: Combines soccer discussion with sharp wit and comedic timing.
• Genuine passion for the game: Hosts’ love for soccer shines through every episode.
• Engaging guest interviews: Features a diverse range of guests, from players to celebrities.
• Strong community connection: Actively engages with listeners, making them feel part of the “Cooligans” family.

From dissecting controversial VAR decisions to interviewing soccer legends and discussing the latest team kits, Alexis and Jesse bring a fresh, relatable perspective to every topic. Their ability to articulate the shared experience of being a soccer fan – the highs, the lows, and the bizarre moments – makes every episode feel like a conversation with trusted friends. For anyone seeking a podcast that delivers both substantive soccer content and an abundance of humor and positive energy, Soccer Cooligans is the undisputed champion, making it the essential listen for every US soccer fan.

Their consistent ability to deliver compelling content that is both informative and joyous is why they sit atop this power ranking, embodying the very best of what US soccer podcasting has to offer.

frequently asked questions about US soccer podcasts